Comparing Sexual Function and Mental Health in Women Using Different Contraceptive Methods
Women often use contraceptives (birth control) during their reproductive years, with options including hormonal (e.g., birth control pills) and non-hormonal methods (e.g., condoms or copper IUDs). While hormonal contraceptives can help reduce the fear of unwanted pregnancy and control menstrual bleeding, they may also negatively affect sexual function and mental health. For example, hormonal contraceptives may lower sexual desire, cause pain during intercourse, and lead to mood changes.
A recent study explored these issues by comparing sexual function, satisfaction, anxiety, and depression among women using hormonal contraceptives, non-hormonal methods, or no contraceptives at all. Understanding these effects can help women choose the most suitable contraceptive method for their needs.
The study involved 315 sexually active women aged 18-45, mostly in committed relationships and with higher education. Participants were recruited through social media and were divided into three groups based on the type of contraceptive they used: hormonal, non-hormonal, or none.
Participants answered a series of questionnaires assessing their sexual function, satisfaction, quality of life, anxiety, and depression. These questionnaires included the Female Sexual Function Index (FSFI), Sexual Quotient–Feminine version, and others that measured mental health and overall well-being. The researchers then compared the effects of different contraceptive methods on sexual health and mental well-being.
Of the 315 women who completed the questionnaires, 51% used hormonal contraceptives, 31% used non-hormonal methods, and 18% used no contraceptives. The study found that women using hormonal contraceptives reported worse sexual function (according to their FSFI scores), lower satisfaction, poorer general health (as shown by lower scores on a 12-item Medical Outcomes Short Form Health Survey), and higher levels of anxiety and depression compared to those using non-hormonal methods or no contraceptives. Non-hormonal contraceptive users experienced better arousal and less pain.
Notably, women who took oral contraceptives were generally younger and experienced worse sexual function and higher anxiety than those using copper IUDs, who reported better outcomes in both arousal and anxiety. The researchers offered a few theories to explain why this might be the case. First of all, they explained that synthetic hormones in most hormonal contraceptives lower testosterone levels, which can reduce arousal and vaginal lubrication, possibly leading to decreased sexual function and satisfaction.
Another potential explanation is the impact of hormonal contraceptives on neurochemistry. Estrogens and progestogens in hormonal methods affect neurotransmitters like serotonin and dopamine, which regulate mood, anxiety, and depression. Therefore, hormonal contraceptive methods, especially those containing progestogens, can alter the activity of enzymes like monoamine oxidase, lowering serotonin levels and increasing mood-related issues, such as anxiety and depression.
While the prevalence of painful sex (dyspareunia) did not differ significantly between the groups, women using hormonal contraceptive methods were more likely to report sexual dysfunction overall.
Despite these findings, the authors of the study emphasized that sexual function is complex and influenced by many factors. Future research is needed to better understand the long-term effects of contraceptives on sexual health and well-being.
For more information on this topic, please read these publications from the ISSM Journals: The Journal of Sexual Medicine, Sexual Medicine Reviews, and Sexual Medicine Open Access:
Oral Contraception and Female Sexual Dysfunction in Reproductive Women
References:
Déa, C. A., Moreira, E. C. H., & Zamboti, C. L. (2024). Sexual function, quality of life, anxiety, and depression in women of reproductive age using hormonal, nonhormonal, and no contraceptive methods. The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 21(8), 683–690. https://doi.org/10.1093/jsxmed/qdae060
You may also be interested in...
Did You Know?
Types of Birth Control and How They Work
February 27, 2024Other Popular Articles
What Is Jelqing, and Does It Actually Work?
The term “jelqing” refers to a set of penis stretching exercises that some believe can make the penis bigger. Although the practice has gained attention and popularity in blogs and internet forums in recent years, there is no scientific evidence that it is an effective way to permanently increase the size of one’s penis. In fact, in some cases, jelqing may actually cause damage to the penis, so it is a good idea to get all the facts before setting off to try it.
What Is Sensate Focus and How Does It Work?
Sensate focus is a technique used to improve intimacy and communication between partners around sex, reduce sexual performance anxiety, and shift away from ingrained, goal-oriented sexual patterns that may not be serving a couple.
What Is the Average Penis Size?
If you have ever wondered how your penis compares to others in terms of size, you are not alone. Many men are curious to know how their penises stack up compared to the average. Unfortunately, general curiosity can sometimes give way to full-on obsession and anxiety about penis size. This can be an unhealthy and often unnecessary fixation, especially because most men who think their penises are too small have perfectly normal-sized penises.
What Is Edging and Why Do People Do It?
Edging is the practice of stopping sexual stimulation before reaching orgasm to prolong a sexual experience. The term stems from the concept of approaching the metaphorical “edge” of orgasm but stopping before going over the edge.
Can Sex Reduce Menstrual Cramps?
The SMSNA periodically receives and publishes ‘guest editorials.’ The current article was submitted by Mia Barnes, a freelance writer and researcher who specializes in women's health, wellness, and healthy living. She is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Body+Mind Magazine.
Having sex while you experience menstrual cramps is healthy and can provide significant benefits. While it might not be the first activity that comes to mind when your PMS or period cramping begins, many people enjoy sex to reduce menstrual cramps, experience increased pleasure and benefit from other advantages. Learn more about having sex while menstrual cramps are happening and how it can help your body.
The Sex-Positivity Movement: What it Means to Be Sex-Positive
You may have heard references to “being sex-positive” or “the sex-positivity movement” in popular culture. Various celebrities have brought attention to this movement by speaking out about their beliefs and personal experiences regarding sexuality, sexual health, body positivity, “slut-shaming,” and sexual assault.
